Monday, January 18, 2016

If the Primates Attend the Marriage Party at Cana of Galilee: Re-imagining and Re-rereading the Story from John 2

His mother said, “Do whatever Jesus tells you.” John 2: 5

Greetings to you all in the name of our God, Our Creator, Redeemer and Sustainer.

In a space of a week the world said good bye to some of the greatest talents of our generation. The loss of the legendary musician David Bowie and the versatile actor, the fame of Snape in Harry Potter Alan Rickman was felt profoundly across the nation. As the world was still coping with these bereavements, the ecclesiastical world particularly the Anglican Communion was on the news this week for several reasons known to you. Where some sections hailed that ‘the biggest schism was prevented in the communion’ on the other hand it was reported that ‘Primates suspends Episcopal Church of USA from full participation in the Anglican Communion.’  Is unity achieved at the expense of exclusion? Or can the split within the Church be fixed temporarily by axing another Church in the name of discipline and order? How are we as a Church the universal broken body of Christ, where one particular Church is slaughtered on the altar of majoritarianism?



When we go into the detail of this week’s meeting we understand that 38 Anglican Primates from around the world gathered together at the invitation of the Archbishop of Canterbury for a week long prayer and discussion on the life and service of God in the world. It was reported that Archbishop of Uganda walked away from the meeting on the second day for not taking disciplinary action on a particular Church until they have repented of their decisions that have torn the fabric of the Anglican Communion. In light of that, hurriedly, the Primates released their leaked communiqué one day prior to actual day of release suspending this Church for three years from full participation in the Anglican Communion. All because, the Episcopal Church has brought in changes to their doctrine of Marriage.

Coincidentally and by the providence of the Spirit the text this morning that has been chosen on the common lectionary, where Anglicans and other Christians are called to preach this Sunday, after a week of hurt and pain is a text, where Jesus and his disciples attend a wedding, a marriage party at Cana from John 2: 1-11. Dear friends, allow me this morning to re-imagine and reread this given text, “Jesus at the Wedding in Cana,” as an ecumenical partner in the faith of Christ, for this week’s decisions of the Primates have huge implications to the global ecclesiology and have a deep relevance to the Christian faith in this our generation.

Taking a clue from last week’s play we watched with our children from our Church, “Ink Heart”, where the reader is captured into the text and becomes a reality into that text, so also I would want to imagine if the Primates, who represent our Christian context are captured into the text of John 2 and participate in the wedding at Cana with Jesus and his disciples, where he turns water into wine. I want to present to you this re-imagination where the Primates, Archbishop of Canterbury, Jesus, his disciples, mother Mary and the narrator engage in a conversation with one another.

Presenting to you the re-imagination and re-reading of John 2 in a narration form. A caveat to this rereading, ‘please don’t take any offences on any of the characters.’

1.On the third day there was a wedding, a marriage party in Cana of Galilee, and the mother of Jesus was the first to attend, for she came to help with the logistics at the marriage party.
Jesus had also been invited to this marriage party.

Archbishop of Canterbury along with his 38 colleagues who are called as Primates also self-invited themselves and attended this marriage function.
The steward at the wedding noticed a bunch of strangers who were dressed in purple with huge crosses on their bellies lingering at the wine section of the party and asked them, “Are you ok? Who do you want to meet?”
The Archbishop of Canterbury came to the front and replied in his bass tone, “Thank you we are ok, we are disciples of Jesus and have come along with him.”
The steward gave a long look at these Bishops and murmured within himself, “Could Jesus not find any better guys than these bunch of cheeky ones. Where on earth did he found them?”
The Primate from Korea who knew lip reading angrily said, “Excuse me my friend, what did you say about us?”
The steward with a grin answered, “nothing nothing, How are you all and warm welcome to this marriage party, let me go and call Peter to come and take you to Jesus.” He quickly disappears to find Peter.
Peter then comes and says, “Hearty welcome Archbishop of Canterbury and to all the 38 Primates. So nice of you Archbishop for bringing them all to this marriage party. Come let us go and meet Jesus. I will also introduce you my other 11 colleagues as well. Mind you Archbishop, we aren’t as Biblically strong as you are all and as powerful as you are all with dioceses and parishes, for we are all very new to this mission with Jesus, in the of discipleship.”
Archbishop replies, “no worries bro, some of our Bishops are here to teach you all guys, for we are coming straight from our fasting prayers during the week.”

Jesus greets the Archbishop and the Primates and invites them all to join along with his disciples to enjoy at the marriage party.

2. Jesus and his disciples had also been invited to the marriage party.
3. When the wine gave out, the mother of Jesus said to him, “They have no wine.”
4. And Jesus said to her, “Woman, what concern is that to you and to me? My hour has not yet come.”
5. His mother said to the stewards at the marriage party, “Do whatever Jesus tells you.”

As the conversation between Jesus and his mother Mary was going on in meeting to the need of the occasion, which is finding more wine, some of the Primates enquired who the wedding couple are and realised that they are a pair from the Episcopal Church of US and the presiding clergy at their wedding was one of the priests of the same Church.

Filled with fury and frustration, some of the Primates whose faith was ultra-rightist started to become uncomfortable and grumbled at each other how disgraceful it is for us to attend this marriage of a couple of this disgraceful church.

Among them, Archbishop of Uganda became vocal and called on Archbishop of Canterbury and said, “Your grace, this is highly unsolicited of us attending a marriage party of a pair from a church that altered the doctrine of marriage, will you kindly take disciplinary action on the Church for such acts or would you want a schism in our communion?”

Archbishop of Canterbury was shocked to hear this and tried to pacify him and said “Your grace, don’t be in a panic, we can address this matter, we can have a consultative process and resolve it.”

At once Archbishop of Uganda replied, “I have been hearing this from so many years, will it possible for you to take a disciplinary action on these Churches or not? Can you restore godly order in our Communion otherwise I will have to walk out of this marriage party”

Archbishop of Canterbury then said, “Since we are here in the presence of Jesus, his disciples and his mother, why don’t we ask them and seek their wisdom and advice on this matter”
Mary, mother of Jesus who was overseeing the marriage party and trying to get more wine as the wine gave out, was walking by that way and on seeing her Archbishop of Canterbury took Archbishop of Uganda and ran towards her.

Mary on seeing them, “Archbishops are you both ok, why is there so much unpleasantness on your faces, I am sorry the wine ran out, and we are trying to address it and soon our jars should be filled with wine, and I am hoping for my son Jesus to fix it for me”

Archbishop of Canterbury replied, “No worries on that mother Mary, we can wait for a long to get some wine. There is a more pressing thing than wine on us, which is bothering our communion.”

Mary asked, “What is more pressing for now than not having sufficient wine?”

Archbishop of Canterbury then shared the conversation that took place between him and Archbishop of Uganda and placed it before mother Mary asking her wisdom on to address it.

Mary smiling at the Archbishops said, “I have told the bartenders at the wedding to do whatever Jesus tells them to do, like wise I say to you both ‘Do as Jesus tells you’” She further said, “This is as simple as that, you don’t need to look for matching references in the Scriptures or don’t need to exclude anyone, but ‘do as Jesus tells you’ for I know my son, for all that he would tell is just love and celebrate love. Anyways I don’t have more time for now; all that I have to say is ‘do as Jesus tells you to do.’”Having said this, Mary ran to find whether new wine was brought forth.

Archbishop of Canterbury said, “ok lets do whatever Jesus tells us to do, what do you say?”

Archbishop of Uganda on hearing this said, “It is not convincing for me. How much of Scriptures does Mary know? In accordance with the resolution of our Provincial Assembly, it was, therefore, necessary for me to withdraw from here. It seemed that I was being manipulated into participating in a long meeting with the Episcopal Church USA and the Anglican Church of Canada without the necessary discipline being upheld.”

Archbishop of Uganda walks out of this marriage party, leaving Jesus, his disciples, Archbishop, the other Primates. Most of them thought that he left unpleasantly because there wasn’t sufficient wine for him to party and merry.

Meanwhile, Archbishop of Canterbury called for an urgent emergency meeting of the Primates and said to them, “Before the news goes to Jesus, let us resolve it ourselves, for we can’t foresee a schism in our Communion. We can slowly convince Jesus of our decision of excluding a Church for the sake of fragile unity among our Communion. Since our Church pews are highly filled in global south than in other contexts, in order to please these people let us unanimously levy sanctions on this Episcopal Church and suspend them from all our activities. Even before Archbishop of Uganda reaches his place, we shall quickly send this communiqué titled “Walking in the service of God to the world” and save our face and Communion. Mind you, let this news not go to Jesus and his disciples.”

The two Indian primates who were present there on the one hand went with Archbishop of Uganda’s perspective of disciplining the church that altered the doctrine of marriage, and on the other hand praised the Episcopal Church of US for their support to the Churches in India during Tsunami. However both of them in their diplomatic style remained neutral and went along with the majority of Primates present there and agreed to these recommendations and released the communiqué.

"Our commitment to be an inclusive church is not based on a social theory or capitulation to the ways of the culture, but on our belief that the outstretched arms of Jesus on the cross are a sign of the very love of God reaching out to us all. While I understand that many disagree with us, our decision regarding marriage is based on the belief that the words of the Apostle Paul to the Galatians are true for the church today: All who have been baptised into Christ have put on Christ. There is no longer Jew or Gentile, slave or free, male or female, for all are one in Christ.” These are the words spoken by the Primate and Presiding Bishop of the excluded Church, which are uttered out of pain and disappointment.

‘Do whatever Jesus tells you’ was reeling in the heads of Archbishop of Canterbury and the rest of the Primates there, for they knew the decision they made was not what Jesus would want them to do. By excluding a Church and suspending a Church for the sake of majoritarianism and populism, is not what Jesus would tell, yet the Bishops went against the conscious of Jesus.

Meanwhile, Jesus called on his friends to fill water in the ritual jars of purification and turned water into wine, addressing the needs of the people and the communities over there and elsewhere. At that moment, water was turned into wine, ritual jars were turned into communitarian fountains of froth, impossibilities were turned into possibilities. All because of doing whatever Jesus told them to do. The bridegroom was surprised, the stewards were surprised, the guests were surprised, mother Mary was surprised, disciples were surprised at this miracle of turning water into wine. By this Jesus’ glory was revealed and his disciples believed him.

Jesus wasn’t interested in which doctrine of marriage did this couple at the wedding at Cana was following; all he did was addressing the needs of the marriage party, its people and their communities. Later on knowing about the communiqué from the Primates of the Anglican Communion, where a Church was excluded, ‘Jesus wept.’

In light of the ongoing exclusions, marginalization, discriminations, and levying sanctions by the powerful against the powerless, the true message for us is spoken by mother Mary, “Do whatever Jesus tells you”, which is ‘love God, love one another, judge not and always embrace the excluded.’

After all of this, the Archbishop of Canterbury forgets what has happened in the week comes forward proudly to announce, “We are working for a common date to celebrate Easter and we are working along with the Vatican, with the Orthodox groups.”

Where the world is not broken into narrow domestic walls, into that heaven of freedom my father, let our Churches awake.

Do whatever Jesus tells you.


Raj Bharath Patta

(This is the text of the Sermon preached at St. Peter’s Church & Chaplaincy, Manchester on 17th January 2016)

Cartoon Courtesy: http://www.weblogcartoons.com/cb/primates07/1.gif



No comments:

In the context of the ongoing war in the land of the Holy-One, which side do you support?

When nearly 9000 people are killed in this brutal war, Which side do I support?   When civilians, hospitals and places of worship, churches ...