Monday, June 29, 2009

Injustice at one place Affects Justice at every place

“I have been a victim of racism in India” was quoted recently as said by the Mizoram Chief Minister Mr. Lalthanhawla in a seminar in Singapore, which has caught the attention of media all across the nation, describing such a statement as an embarrassment to the Indian pride. This statement also comes at a time when Indian students in Australia are being beaten up on the count of racism, creating a situation of fear and threatening. Today, I have seen a cartoon, where an Australian student studying India is manhandling an Indian on the same pretext of racism. Certainly such forms of violence and racist activities needs to be condemned and the law needs to be enforced in such cases, across the globe. Several protest rallies by the students have been organized by Indian students in Australia and in India to condemn such activities and have been demanding to provide safety and security to all Indians there. The politicians have been raising their voices in and out of Parliament to address this issue of attacks on Indian students abroad. Discussions with Australian political leaders are on, articles requesting Indian students to assimilate with Australian culture and people have been voluminous, the ministry of External Affairs has been on the job, the ministry of Oversees Indian Affairs has been working hard and counselling to the victims is also on the move. As I pen down my thoughts, there is news that two Indians are assaulted in Sydney. Discrimination and hate campaigns against colour and race needs to be condemned and should be on the top priority of the international community in addressing it. I was pleased to see the FIFA football match between the USA and the Spain, where before the match began, when both the teams stand for the guard of honour, the captains of both the teams said at last, “ Let us say NO to RACISM”. Such gestures can serve as a token to make understand people in overcoming racism. I wish when India and Australia plays next a cricket match, if both the captains on behalf of their countries announce “no to racism and no to discrimination, for all of us as human beings are one and equal”, for such gestures also will send in the message of equality.

But what comes to me, as surprise is that all of a sudden racism comes to the forefront, and there have been discussions on this topic on all most every television channels and news columns. Is racism a new phenomenon that we have been caught by its sensation today? Is discrimination by colour something new to our Indian society? Or is it because such attacks are done to Indians on a foreign land that there is a lot of hue and cry? Does our Indian society and Indian political leadership have forgotten that in our own land from several ages, there have been a community of people called Dalits, who have been discriminated, ostracized and are being beaten up every day just on the similar grounds of race, or even a worse form called caste? Do caste discriminations and attacks on people in the name of caste not attract the Indian media and public? Does our Indian government give heed to the plights of these our Dalit brothers & sisters? I am not sure how to go about in answering these realistic questions of our times.

Discrimination on Dalits, violence on Dalits, and violation of human rights to Dalits have been an ongoing saga from ages in India. Caste has been one of the cruel forms that have divided our society and unfortunately it has crept deep into our societies and families that we are least bothered to address such inhuman system, which divides and discriminates people. Discrimination and exclusion have been dominating not only the rural contexts of India, but also the higher places of learning centers are not free from such evil forces. Dalit students are beaten up, Dalit students have been looked down and humiliated on the basis of caste, at some places the government schemes allotted for Dalit students have not been implemented and some even staged protests over the reservations and preferential options given to Dalits in India. When Dalit students were brutally attacked in Ambedkar Law University in Chennai, how many responsible citizens of India raised their voice? There are several incidents to be quoted, and the question still remains, are Dalits safe in India?

I am reminded of the saying, “injustice done at one place affects justice at every place”. Therefore, when there has been a great pressure on the government on India from all section of people to act on the attacks on Indian students in Australia, and provide them safety and security, I am of the opinion that the same pressure needs to be kept on the government to address the attacks on Dalits and the discriminations done to them. Let’s not forget, that since it is mostly upper middle class and upper class and caste, who can afford to study abroad when attacked, the government makes sure that no stone is left unturned in bringing the situation to normalcy. But when the poor Dalits are marginalized, discriminated, excluded and beaten up, on a daily basis, hardly there is any one to be in solidarity with them and to present their case with the government in ensuring justice to them. I think it is high time, that we as civil society needs to take up this cause of Dalits on prime importance with the attacks on Indian students in Australia and strive to be the harbingers of peace and justice. Justice, liberation, safety, freedom, equality and peace need to be ensured to Dalits in India on every front of life. India needs to be free from all sorts of discriminations, India’s unity in diversity can be witnessed when the last of the Dalits is free from the clutches of caste, India as a cradle of all major religions will be vibrant, when every faith opposes and destroys caste from its labyrinth, India as a pride for software technologies will be creative, when every industry upholds the values of equality and fraternity, with a preferential option for Dalits, and India as a developing nation will sustain, when stratification of society on the basis of caste discrimination is buried and when all its citizens live in total freedom and peace. To that vision of India, may my India remain truthful and committed for a just and inclusive community.

29.06.2009

7 comments:

Dinesh said...

Hey bharat.. good to see u blogging after a long time..:) i like to read and comment on ur blog as u raise the issues of my interest too.

You have hit the nail on its head!!! the govt is turning a blind eye to the everyday racial (caste based) discrimination meted out to the dalits and adivasis in our country. Dalits are beaten, humiliated, killed on a daily basis. In Delhi the Northeast grils are till today called as "chinkies" and everyone takes the liberty to make a pass at them. Even after living here for 25-30 years, NEI friends are not accepted as "delhiites".

But as u have pointed out, because its the Upper Caste, Upper Class students, who forms more than 90% of the Indian students community who are in Australia for higher studies, are attacked, the media as well as the government is making it such a hue and cry. After all, most of these upper caste and elite students cannot qualify in the tough entrance tests in India for admissions and
manage to BUY seats abroad - paying hefty capitation fees. And the media, which is governed and controlled by out and out Upper Caste people, are bound to make a brouhaha about these attacks.

Its high time that the media, stop counting the no. of assaults which is around 18 only till now I guess, none of them fatal, and focus on the racial discrimination and assault, murder and rape on the dalits and adivasis within our very own country. The National Crime Records Bureau of India reports: “Every hour — two Dalits are assaulted; every day — three Dalit women are raped, two Dalits are murdered and two Dalit houses are burnt.” And what the upper caste infested media and the govt is doing on this??

Thanks again bharat for bringing this issue for discussion.

monica said...

HI Anna,
The articles written by you are throwing a great light on the present situations and also on christian life.

Please continue write on the Topics which God is directing to you.May the Algmighty God shower his richest blessings upon you.
Yours in christ,
B.Monica

Peoples' Theology said...

Bharath,

Every hour there are Dalits, Women and children in this country (India) are attacked but no Media talks about it. Recently 100, 1000 of innocent women, men, children and grannies were attacked, killed in Sri Lanka, where were these Media? Is it a Media Ethics? Becasue most of the Sri Lankan Tamils are Dalits and BCs so no media bothers, media cries for asutralia because the students are uppercaste!is it Media justice? Where are we?

Good articulation congrats, keep it up.

Yours in Solidarity,
Christopher Rajkumar - NCCI

Unknown said...

Bharath, I had the pleasure of going through your write up, and I readily agree with your thoughts about the Governmental dynamics in dealing with racism, and especially our own form of racism, i.e., caste system.

It’s also time that we used the term ‘racism’ for caste system. This would be a good way to “Globalise to Consientize” the outside world about caste sytem. That may readily draw the attention of the readers and thinkers. I am not saying anything new here. I am only reminded of A statement submitted to the National committee set up by the Prime minister of India (facilitated by the UNE division of the Ministry of External Affairs- Govt. of India) in preparation for the Durban Conference- 2001 which suggested that any discrimination based on class, gender, caste and tribe to be treated as “racial”. I’ve understood that the Bangkok conference has pushed forward the matter hard so that economic (the so called “developing”) status is not our only concern. Economic agenda is- as well known- the top priority of the mostly upper middle class and upper class and caste in India and elsewhere, overshadowing caste system!

thanks for your thoughts

raj bharath patta said...

thanks to Dinesh, Monica, Christopher and Rohan for your comments and for culling out newer areas of concern, in this direction. The issue of media addressing issues, the way the government address each issue and the nexus between racism and casteism, i think are all certainly important to keep our discussion going. Personally i feel, race cannot be equated with caste, for caste is some thing unique in its discrimination, and calls for definite and distinct methodologies in addressing it.

theology-christopher said...

Yes, Bharath, I agree with you that, casteism is entairely different from racism.

Gwendolyn Walker said...

Son, I follow your articles closely as it leads me in the right direction of prayer. My heart goes out to all who are raped, murdered and abused in any way shape or form.

This is what the Lord says: He will turn around your captivity. He will deliver you out of trouble. He will make an end to your enemies - finish them off for good and for ever. Although your afflictions seem incurable and your wounds severe, He will retore your health and heal your wounds.

God says, He will break the oppressor's yoke and burst your bonds. God says that He will take those who are called the "Outcasts" -- the ones who God has forgotten and does not favor" and strengthen you to build upon your ruins. He will have mercy on your dwelling places, and He will bring you to places of safety. He will bless your children and make them great. God will make the enemy glorify Him Him though your people. You will see.

God is sending a whirlwind...a continuing whirlwhind. It shall fall with pain upon the head of the wicked. The fierce anger of the LORD shall not return, until He hath done it, and until He has performed the intents of his heart: in the coming days, you shall know it.

In the context of the ongoing war in the land of the Holy-One, which side do you support?

When nearly 9000 people are killed in this brutal war, Which side do I support?   When civilians, hospitals and places of worship, churches ...